• Home
  • About/Contact
  • Archives
  • Royal Events Calendar
  • RoyaltyNow! Broadcasts
  • Support MBR
Home > Events > Criticized Queen Out-Lives Victoria

Criticized Queen Out-Lives Victoria

30, December, 2007 Mandy Discuss it What they said

I lied. I had to post this before getting cracking on my U.S. government class.

The week of Dec. 24th, 2007 saw HM Elizabeth II surpass Queen Victoria to become Britain’s longest-living monarch.

It is an historic time, but also a time for criticism, apparently. At least if you’re David Starkey.

Starkey, a well-known royal historian who has been declared “The Rudest Man In Britain”, recently commented on the Queen in the Guardian.

“I think she’s got elements a bit like Goebbels in her attitude to culture,” Starkey told the republican newspaper. “…I suppose it’s this absence of any kind of, to be blunt, serious education.”

The interview with Starkey, unimaginatively titled “The Queen and I” , refers to the days of King George V who changed the family name to Windsor, shifting them away from their German connections and giving them more of an “English” look. George V’s changes helped keep the monarchy running, and Starkey insinuates that if the Queen doesn’t do something just as ground-breaking in her family, all will turn to choking dust and disappear on the wind. First up: get a “serious” education for Her Majesty.

Starkey even suggests that the monarchy should remove itself from the Church of England and – contrary to many opinions – look to Prince Charles as their best hope for survival.

Read his interview, then send me your thoughts via email or comment here at the blog!

So, is he to be called David “Snarkey” now, or do you agree with him?

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Tags: HM Queen Elizabeth II
  • http://www.mandysroyalty.org Mandy

    That’s true, people do make careers out of controversy. “The Rudest Man In Britain” may not be the most ideal title to some, but Starkey is getting his media attention, isn’t he? :-)

  • http://www.mandysroyalty.org/ Mandy

    That’s true, people do make careers out of controversy. “The Rudest Man In Britain” may not be the most ideal title to some, but Starkey is getting his media attention, isn’t he? :-)

  • http://www.webwritereditor.com Lisa

    Hello Mandy,
    I don’t agree with him at all and I think that Starkey tends to take the easy way out in his history which is pretty simplified, so he shouldn’t comment like this! He didn’t discuss whether Richard III really murdered the two princes, for example – he just took it as read.

    I agree that Prince Charles probably is more intellectual than the Queen, but she has been intelligent enough to do an excellent job, have a happy marriage and maintain high moral standards herself. She has been an excellent Queen.

    He just wants to be controversial – many people make a career out of this nowadays, unfortunately.

    Who cares what he thinks? I’m sure that the Queen certainly doesn’t!

    Best Regards,
    Lisa

  • http://www.webwritereditor.com/ Lisa

    Hello Mandy,
    I don’t agree with him at all and I think that Starkey tends to take the easy way out in his history which is pretty simplified, so he shouldn’t comment like this! He didn’t discuss whether Richard III really murdered the two princes, for example – he just took it as read.

    I agree that Prince Charles probably is more intellectual than the Queen, but she has been intelligent enough to do an excellent job, have a happy marriage and maintain high moral standards herself. She has been an excellent Queen.

    He just wants to be controversial – many people make a career out of this nowadays, unfortunately.

    Who cares what he thinks? I’m sure that the Queen certainly doesn’t!

    Best Regards,
    Lisa

HM ‘Blooms’ at British Art Show Time Waits For No Man(dy)
RSS
Email Twitter
Home: Mandy's British Royalty

Anglotopia

Jubilee News

  • Queen Elizabeth II: How Her Majesty lost her heart slow dancing to a show tune ... - Daily Mail - May 22, 2012
  • Queen Backed Prince William in Wedding Guest List - ABC News - May 22, 2012
  • Queen Elizabeth II Attends Chelsea Flower Show in London - International Business Times - May 21, 2012
  • Queen Elizabeth II takes in military parade for Diamond Jubilee - CBS News - May 21, 2012
  • Queen Elizabeth's Stylist: A Servant Breaks In The Queen's Shoes - NPR (blog) - May 21, 2012

powered by Google News Just Better 1.2 plugin

Sources

  • .Official website of The Diamond Jubilee
  • .Royal Houses
  • 2012 Diamond Jubilee [store]
  • Books
  • British History Online
  • Coburg Conspiracy, The
  • Denmark
  • Deo Juvante: History of the Grimaldis
  • Diamond Jubilee Info
  • Gemvara
  • Georgian Jewelry
  • Glittering Royal Events
  • Home
  • House of Bourbon-Two Sicilies
  • House of Savoy
  • House of Thurn und Taxis
  • IML + The CMA
  • Lord Mountbatten
  • Luxembourg
  • Mad Hattery
  • Majesty Magazine
  • Marie-Chantal: Boutique
  • Medals of the World
  • Miller Sisters, The
  • Monaco
  • Monaco Government
  • Monarchist League of AU
  • Monarchy of Tonga
  • National Gallery, The
  • Netherlands
  • Netty’s Royalty Page
  • Neuschwanstein castle
  • Nights In The Past
  • Norman Hartnell
  • Norway
  • Official British Monarchy Site
  • Portugal
  • Prince Albert II Foundation
  • Princely House of Liechtenstein
  • Princess Caroline
  • Princess Elizabeth Archives
  • Princess Palace
  • Prussia
  • Queen’s Images, The
  • Regia Anglorum
  • Ritva.com
  • Royal Asscher
  • Royal Collection, The
  • Royal Dutch Jewels
  • Royal House of Portugal
  • Royal Houses, The
  • Royal Magazin
  • Royal Mint, The
  • Sachsen-Coburg und Gotha
  • Serbia
  • Spain
  • St. George’s Chapel
  • Sweden
  • Theodore’s Royalty and Monarchy
  • Unofficial British Royal Family Pages
  • Views and News From Norway
  • World Civic Heraldry Guide
  • WorldRoots

Blog Fellows

  • Altezza Reale (IT)
  • Arbitrary History Blog
  • Blogging Young Fogey
  • BritishRoyals.info
  • Camilla Tominey
  • Charlotte Casiraghi
  • Cross of Laeken
  • Dag Trygsland Hoelseth
  • Danish Royal Watchers
  • Deo Juvante: History of the Grimaldis
  • Edwardian Promenade
  • Lottie Tea
  • Lux-arazzi
  • Mad Monarchs
  • Marilyn’s Royal Blog
  • Medievalists.net
  • Monarchie.cz (Czech)
  • Monarchist League of Iowa
  • Monarchist, The
  • New Adventures of Queen Victoria
  • New York Jewelry Diary
  • Norwegianne's Blog Royale
  • Order of Splendor
  • Princely Family of Monaco
  • Princess Palace
  • Radical Royalist
  • RDujour
  • Royal Book News
  • Royal Forums Blog, The
  • Royal Jewels of The World
  • Royal Musings
  • Royal Portraits
  • Royal Rendezvous
  • Royal Romance
  • Royal Travel and Events
  • Royal Universe, The
  • Royal World
  • RoyalBlog.nl
  • Royalist, The
  • Royalty In The News
  • Scandalous Women
  • Sofia's Royalty
  • Spanish Royals, The
  • The Royal Correspondent
  • Views and News From Norway
  • Vivian’s House of Orange
  • World of Royalty
  • Writer of Queens
  • Young Royal News

Contents

  • Announcements
  • Authors
  • Commentary
  • Controversy
  • Crown vs Republic
  • Events
  • For Your Interest
  • Government
  • Greece
  • Haute Royale
  • History
  • In Memoriam
  • Interviews
  • Jewels and Tiaras
  • MBR
  • Miscellaneous
  • Monarchies
    • Australia
    • Belgium
    • Canada
    • Denmark
    • Japan
    • Jordan
    • Luxembourg
    • Monaco
    • Netherlands
    • New Zealand
    • Norway
    • Spain
    • Sweden
    • United Kingdom
  • Palaces + Castles
  • Picture of the Mo'
  • Style + Glamour
  • The Media
  • Uncategorized
  • United States

The Media

  • Aftenposten
  • B.T. news Denmark
  • Blauw Bloed
  • Copenhagen Post
  • Daily Mail
  • Diez Minutos
  • Hello Magazine Online
  • Huffington Post
  • In Royal Circles
  • Mail + Guardian: South Africa
  • Monaco Hebdo
  • Peter Hitchens’ Blog
  • Point de Vue
  • Royal Photographer Ian Pelham Turner
  • RoyalNews.de
  • Sky News
  • Svensk Damtidning
  • Telegraph: Royal Family
  • The Daily Beast: Royalist
  • The Guardian
  • The Independent
  • The New York Times
  • TMZ
  • Victoria Arbiter

Diamond Jubilee

  • .Official website of The Diamond Jubilee
  • 2012 Diamond Jubilee [store]
262502_125x125 January/Garnet Birthstone Jewelry
Mandy's British Royalty

Deo Juvante

Sovereign Goods

RoyaltyNow!

Royal Educational Society

Princess Maxima's orange diamond!

Find Princess Letizia's Bulgari ring!

Go glam with London Blue Topaz!

.

.

Follow @mandysroyalty

.

My Zimbio

Quantcast
Top WordPress
Copyright © 2003-2012 The Royal Representative
Theme by NeoEase and edited by M.L. Littlefield. Valid XHTML 1.1 and CSS 3.